--- title: "PA/02927/24: sanction changes to apartment approved in PA9349/18 in Mgarr | PropertyList" url: https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-02927-24/mgarr-sanction-changes-to-apartment-approved-in-pa9349-18 source: PropertyList (propertylist.mt), from the Malta Planning Authority's public register retrieved: 2026-11-03 --- > Refused planning application in Mgarr: To sanction changes to apartment approved in PA9349/18. Perit Robert Musumeci LL.D., Perit. Validated 22 May 2024. Planning applications › Mgarr › PA0292724 # PA/02927/24: sanction changes to apartment approved in PA9349/18 in Mgarr 218, Flat 1, Antonia, Triq Sir Harry Luke, Mgarr To sanction changes to apartment approved in PA9349/18. - **Status:** Refused (This application has been refused by Planning Board / Commission and a refusal notification has been sent.) - **Location:** 218, Flat 1, Antonia, Triq Sir Harry Luke, Mgarr - **Locality:** [Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/planning-applications/mgarr) - **Applicant:** Maria Isabella Vella - **Perit:** [Dr Robert Musumeci LL.D., Perit](https://propertylist.mt/perit/robert-musumeci-ll-d-perit) - **Application type:** Full development permission - **Zone:** Within Development Zone - **Type of works:** Sanctioning - **Residential units:** 1 - **Received:** 26 March 2024 - **Validated:** 22 May 2024 - **Published:** 22 May 2024 - **Comments close:** 21 June 2024 - **Recommendation:** Refuse Permission - **Decision:** Refuse Permission - **Decision date:** 31 January 2025 [Case details on the Planning Authority website](https://www.pa.org.mt/pacasedetails?CaseType=PA/02927/24) [Plans, case officer report and decision on eapps](https://eapps.pa.org.mt/Case/CaseDetails?caseType=PA&casenumber=02927&caseYear=24) ## Planning activity around 218, Flat 1, Antonia, Triq Sir Harry Luke, Mgarr 92 other applications within 300 m: 59 granted, 4 refused, 7 pending. 94% of decided applications nearby were granted. Tallest granted nearby: 4 floors (PA/03858/24). On Triq Sir Harry Luke: 31 other applications, 21 granted and 2 refused; granted buildings are typically 4 floors, the tallest 4. Periti active on this street: [Daniel Muscat](https://propertylist.mt/perit/daniel-muscat), [M&V Architects](https://propertylist.mt/perit/m-and-v-architects), [Falzon & Cutajar](https://propertylist.mt/perit/falzon-and-cutajar), [Martin Farrugia](https://propertylist.mt/perit/martin-farrugia), [Philip Micallef](https://propertylist.mt/perit/philip-micallef). Approval estimate for sanctioning applications like this here: about 91% (likely range 61–100%, low reliability, from 24 comparable decisions nearby). Indicative only. It's based on decisions for similar nearby applications, not on the drawings or the case officer's report; it gets better as documents are added from eapps. - [**PA/01982/23** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-01982-23/mgarr-facade-maintenance-and-restoration-including-the-restoration): Facade maintenance and restoration including the restoration and or replacement of apertures. Granted, validated 18 May 2023, 24 m away - [**PA/07068/24** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-07068-24/mgarr-construction-of-ground-floor-car-spaces): Proposed construction of ground floor car spaces, two overlying apartments at first and second floor level and proposed penthouse at receded floor level. Granted, validated 23 October 2024, 3 floors plus a receded floor, 39 m away - [**PA/07231/23** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-07231-23/mgarr-change-of-use-of-existing-pre-1967-residence): Proposed change of use of existing pre-1967 residence to Class 4D premises. Proposal includes internal alterations at all levels, extension at second floor… Granted, validated 6 December 2023, 41 m away - [**PA/04063/26** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-04063-26/mgarr-sanctioning-of-shop-sign-and-minor-sanctioning): Proposed sanctioning of shop sign and minor sanctioning to existing basement and ground floor Class 5B from previous approved permit PA4064/00. Proposed… Pending, validated 17 June 2026, 3 floors plus a receded floor, 44 m away - [**PA/01619/26** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-01619-26/mgarr-propose-extension-of-staircase-and-lift-on): To propose extension of staircase and lift on roof at fourth floor level. Granted, validated 11 March 2026, 54 m away - [**PA/02333/24** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-02333-24/mgarr-demolish-existing-garage): To demolish existing garage. Proposed construction of 2 garages at ground floor level and construction of 2 apartments and a duplex penthouse. Granted, validated 24 April 2024, 54 m away - [**PA/02676/22** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-02676-22/mgarr-demolish-existing-street-level-garage-and-to): To demolish existing street level garage and to construct a maisonette. Withdrawn, 63 m away - [**PA/01327/26** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-01327-26/mgarr-fix-4-retractable-awnings): To fix 4 retractable awnings Refused, validated 4 March 2026, 64 m away - [**PA/03057/24** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-03057-24/mgarr-sanction-minor-difference-in-facade-opening-and): To sanction minor difference in facade opening and change of use from domestic store approved in PA5584/20 to a garage for private cars. Refused, validated 29 May 2024, 69 m away - [**PA/07486/25** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-07486-25/mgarr-awning-over-tables-and-chairs-approved-in): Proposed awning over tables and chairs approved in DNO891/11. Refused, validated 26 November 2025, 71 m away - [**PA/03858/24** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-03858-24/mgarr-1): 1. Demolition of existing store. 2. Construction of a single 4-storey residential dwelling. Granted, validated 4 September 2024, 4 floors, 79 m away - [**PA/02973/23** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-02973-23/mgarr-outdoor-catering-area-on-public-open-space): Proposed outdoor catering area on public open space comprising of tables and chairs. Granted, validated 31 May 2023, 84 m away - [**PA/00512/22** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-00512-22/mgarr-internal-alterations-and-division-of-residential-unit): Internal alterations and division of residential unit from commercial unit. Change from Class 4B to Class 4D. Formation of new shop front, and installation of… Status being checked, 84 m away - [**PA/03864/23** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-03864-23/mgarr-sanctioning-of-existing-pre-1968-townhouse-as-built): Sanctioning of existing pre-1968 townhouse as built, covering variations from approved PB/947/73. Pending, validated 28 June 2023, 86 m away - [**PA/00792/22** Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-00792-22/mgarr-demolition-of-existing-maisonette-and-construction-of): Proposed demolition of existing maisonette and construction of a ground floor maisonette, a street level 2-car garage and 2 apartments on first and second… Status being checked, 3 floors plus a receded floor, 86 m away ## More by Robert Musumeci LL.D., Perit - [**PA/07369/26** Zabbar](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-07369-26/zabbar-modification-to-pa1896-23): Modification to PA1896/23, elimination of washroom at roof level, and construction of a separate apartment. Pending, validated 21 October 2026 - [**PA/06465/26** Attard](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-06465-26/attard-partial-demolition): Partial demolition, extension, internal and external alterations to existing dwelling to create 3 separate dwellings, 2 garages and a carport. Application… Pending, validated 23 September 2026, 1 floor - [**PA/06371/26** Mellieha](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-06371-26/mellieha-placing-of-a-double-sided-static-billboard-with): Placing of a double-sided static billboard with internal LED lighting Suspended, validated 16 September 2026 - [**PA/06118/26** Kalkara](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-06118-26/kalkara-changes-to-pa1217-17-in-order-to-construct): Proposed changes to PA1217/17 in order to construct two dwellings, basement garage and swimming pools. Pending, validated 9 September 2026 - [**PA/04852/26** Balzan](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-04852-26/balzan-sanction-variations-from-pa3016-25-to-existing-residential): To sanction variations from PA3016/25 to existing residential units. Pending, validated 15 July 2026 - [**PA/04622/26** Zurrieq](https://propertylist.mt/permit/PA-04622-26/zurrieq-construction-of-agricultural-store-with-basement-and): Proposed construction of agricultural store with basement and reservoir. Suspended, validated 15 July 2026 [All applications by Robert Musumeci LL.D., Perit](https://propertylist.mt/perit/robert-musumeci-ll-d-perit) [All planning applications in Mgarr](https://propertylist.mt/planning-applications/mgarr)